Minthara and halsin in party Halsin was at the party, enjoying the "stimulating company" of goblins and especially happy not to be in charge of the grove anymore . It would be a good way to conclude the grove vs goblins situation if both of them are in the party. Gather your party and venture forth! Obviously, Minthara doesn't know that Halsin exists at all and I couldn't talk to her about it. Have Withers store their souls. There's no companions preventing you to recruit another. You get the party and the romance scene, and then are free to revive Wyll and Karlach after that. Yes, and they sleep together. The urge to just start all over to have every companion in my playthrough is driving me mad. She’s a deadly Paladin that wields two blades at once and serves the Cult of the Absolute. She will heal your party during that fight. Have them jump into the chasm. Halsin represents the good path, while Minthara is very evil-aligned. Halsin and Minthara are two opposing companions in Baldur’s Gate 3. The Grove will be decimated (along with the shopkeeper), Halsin will be unavailable and the Shadow Curse cannot be lifted. 7) done :-D or is it this one? Not 100% tested yet, but the following steps seem to work: You can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. 6 - Save halflings, save zevlor and finish the act. The Grove will be decimated (along with the shopkeeper), Halsin will be unavailable and the Shadow Curse Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s Gate 3. More posts you may like Related Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming forward back. 5 - Go to camp and you'll see minthara and halsin, now you can recruit halsin to the team. If you knock her out and kill the other 2 leaders, the grove is safe. They're getting along famously. And I rescued Szazz, which I had forgotten. Then Minthara bugged out and I had to kill her and resurrect her, then everything was fine. To get her to join, you must help Is it possible to get both as party members if I incapacitate Minthra when she attacks the Grove rather than killing her? Don't know if it matters but after she left to attack the This guide explains how to recruit Minthara on a “Good Playthrough” in Baldur’s Gate 3 without killing Tieflings. Treat that as a privilege, not as a platform to ask for more in this context. Once you’re in Act 2, you can do the recruiting quests for both Minthara and Halsin like normal. Then they fixed the issue with Minthara and Halsin sharing the same tent in camp (they gave it to We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Thus you get Halsin in act 1 (sort of. i painted Minthara and Moonrise Tower! 2. You can get her in act 2 this way, and keep everyone except Halsin. BG3 is Gather your party and venture forth! Minthara + Halsin NOTE: I'd killed Gut, freed Halsin and told him to wait in the Worg pens. Their intended quest lines involve thwarting the other. I hope they add some interactions between Minthara and Halsin in the next patch or hot fix. However, in EA patch 9, there was a way to get Minthara and Halsin together (technically). He will travel to the inn. That means going to Last Light Inn and looking for Thaniel to recruit Halsin and going to Moonrise And in Act 2, Minthara and Haslin are both in camp at the same time and can be placed into a party on the most recent patch with no mods? I have a save file from before Patch 1, where I To add both of them to your party you have to save Halsin and make him wait for you in the prison, then recruit Minthara first and him later in Act 2. Why EXACTLY is Tavern Brawler so OP? I think it is still a bit bugged, Thaniel just hangs around with Minthara. Just don’t bring Halsin when you’re trying to recruit her. In Act II they share a tent because they’re not intended to both be there, but it’s possible. Gale will too if his opnion is low and you fail his checks. Ignore the Goblin Leaders. Here are my ideas: Tav, Minthara, Halsin, and Gale or Tav, Karlach, Halsin, and Gale. The next day, I found Minthara in Zevlor's cave. You can still recruit and have Halsin in your party. Halsin and all the tieflings randomly died in act 2 upvote It's impossible to recruit halsin if you raid the grove. SPOILER. The fact that they allowed an an entire questline to be left unresolved is already a bonus. Thanks to Reddit user u/DJay_lost for sharing this method. I looted the grove and went to the goblin party with her. Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. Walnut stampede! Super_Yamcha 11 months ago #10. Idk if I should or just continue and make a new play later. 5) You save Minthara and she joins your party. Then tell Minthara you agree to help kill the grove. . Went to towers. I personally got Halsin recruited to my party (so did his portal request), and added him to my party. Some have even reported Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s This quest allows you to gain one of two characters — you can either unlock the friendly Druid Halsin or the evil Paladin So now that it's possible to recruit Halsin and Minthara both in a good run (save the Tieflings and knock out Minthara while she's temporaily hostile in Goblin camp, as of hotfix 5) has anyone actually done it? (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. There was code for having Minthara available to join your party, because you could choose to side with her over the Grove. 6) You progress the quest from Halsin until he offers to become permanent companion. Then you return for Halsin and tell him about the sleeping guy. Though for best results, you might want to The designated way to gain Minthara was to kill Tieflings and Halsin. Yes, you can recruit both Minthara and Halsin. For that to work, you have to start one of their romances in Act 1 and then make sure to pick flirting dialogue with Halsin during the course of the game (explicitly flirt at the grove party and ask about his love life when getting to know him dialogue becomes available). His dialogue is different if you already talked to Minthara. The only real switch is Karlach and Minthara, but I intend to keep that slot for a melee focused character to balance my Tav and Gale as spellcasters. I am over 70hrs into the game and I find this out. I think this upsets Halsin so he disappears a lot and sometimes just pops up in random places in camp, whittling away. Reply reply However Minthara is very bugged, and even though she has lines acknowledging Wyll and Karlach they also have some lines referencing her which you can't normally hear. Lost halsin and minthara the same day on honor Mode lol Reunited Thaniel and Oliver without Halsin in party comments. In act 2, I freed Minthara and helped Halsin remove the curse. However, she must be "temporarily Recruiting Minthara & Halsin. After she escapes, Minthara will join your party as a permanent party member. But now that you can have both Halsin and Minthara, I had the thought: Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Turn on non-lethal and knock her out (final blow can’t be magic or an arrow). So I reloaded my save and convinced Halsin that I'm only interested in him and my other relationship is over, no need to talk to anyone. Levelled her up, and good to go. Since patch 5, you can recruit Minthara as your companion and Gather your party and venture forth! But they don't get any interactions, for example you can't ask Minthara her opinion about Halsin and they don't get any dialogues when both are together. To do so you must enable non-lethal attack and knock her out while doing the "kill the three leaders" quest for Zevlor/Halsin. Also, BTW, although it came as a surprise to me - people were expecting a confrontation - nah, Halsin gained inspiration when Minthara joined the party. Knocked her out at the Goblin Camp (I handled her second and immediately went to Dror who I attacked while he was talking to the dead mindflayer and received the necessary Quest completions) Before talking to Minthara, collect Karlach and Wyll. Reply reply More replies. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Now that Minthara is en route, go to Halsin. I have both of them on my current playthrough. Kept Halsin in my party, kicked another person out when we got to camp after rescuing her. Minthara and Halsin together is a bug, and you lose more than Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Lunaa- Honestly I don't care about Halsin, if the choice was to kill Minthara or Halsin I would keep Minthara gamewise (to have all different classes, except monk, since I am sorc), but slaughtering the whole grove with tieflings and druids in it are not that appealing as slaughtering Shadowheart and Astarion are the only polyamorous companions in the game and only with Halsin. r Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. She can also be romanced. Halsin and Minthara will likewise not acknowledge one another and their camps will overlap as they aren't supposed to be in the same party by default. She was very happy and thankful. Also if you skip the Grove vs Goblin and go straight to act 2 and save minthara (if you don't want to get your hands dirty while also want to get minthara) Halsin will be found dead in the worg pen. Has lead to some awkward moments 😅 Minthara was sitting right there last night when Halsin propositioned my Tav, and presumably noticed when he snuck off later that night Fast-forward to this morning when she asks to read Tav’s thoughts, and I can only assume Tav and Halsin are exchanging glances over her shoulder knowing those thoughts Well beside Halsin/Minthara that are mutually exclusive, unless you find a very twisted and not intended way. Everyone else is recruitable and able to be partied with each other, even if you take an evil route and destroy the Grove. But this should only be possible if you knocked her unconscious at the goblin camp. That doesn't affect anything gameplay-wise, it's just funny to see What I remember doing was: Rescued Halsin from his cell and talked to him, went into act 2 without triggering the raid, rescued Minthara and added her to my party without long resting, traveled back to act 1, long rested, and Halsin showed up in camp. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. pretty sure he means how did you get all the companions without them randomly quitting the party? siding with minthara alone nromally makes will, karlach and halsin instantly abandon you. Remember, Halsin is in to threesomes and foursomes. Since patch 5, you can recruit Minthara as your companion and even a romance interest on a good playthrough without killing Tieflings and Druids in Emerald Grove. Enter the interrogation room and talk to the interrogators, then attack them. ) Then in act 2 you can save/recruit Minthara. But by keeping both stories Here’s how to rescue Minthara and put her on your team without slaughtering innocents or making half of your party leave permanently. She will appear in act 2 and you can get her to join your team. This is what you need to do to recruit Minthara and stay You can still recruit and have Halsin in your party. According to a reddit post from yesterday, in order to have Karlach and Wyll in the same party as Minthara is you have to completely ignore the attack the grove quest. r/BaldursGate3. (Same for Karlach and Wyll, both will leave the party if you try to raid the grove with them) To get them both you have to side with the grove and kill the goblin leaders, but use non-lethal attacks to knock out minthara rather than killing her. After killing everyone but left Minthara knocked down, I went back and escaped with Halsin, Then I went to the Grove and turned his quest, got all the rewards, I even stole the Idol for Mol. I think of this every time I see the icon for Banish You can 100% get Both Minthara and Halsin in your party without issue. Talked to her, she instantly joined my party. Went to prison, rescued Minthara. He was excited and told me to await him that night. They occupy the same tent in camp though (maybe because they were intended to be mutually exclusive, idk). So in a pre-Patch 5/unmodded playthrough, you could simultaneously romance either Astarion or Shadowheart alongside Halsin or Minthara (whichever you recruited). Technically speaking, Halsin/Minthara is the only choice you have to make. Be warned that Minthara can be buggy no matter what, especially if you recruit her through the non-normal method (knocking her out vs siding with her against the Grove). Of course some specific story decisions might make them leave the party, but there's no decision in the game beside Halsin/Minthara that will result into making one leave or make I have two potential parties depending on if I recruit Minthara or not. It 4 - Go to the prison and free minthara (no need to save the halfings/gnomes yet) and fight your way out of moonlight tower (around the kitchen counter clockwise from the balcony is the safest way). Have Zrell show compassion for Minthara and she gets sent to the prisons. That way you If you rescue Halsin, he will force you to wipe out the goblin (that includes minthara, even though you already recruited her). upvotes Rescue halsin like normal, talk to Minthara but don’t get into a fight through dialogue. It depends on how you deal with Minthara. In this case, you refuse to kill the three goblin leaders and progress to Act 2 without resolving the conflict. Top 1% Rank by size . Help him, and kill all of the goblins in the room. In the prison, kill the scrying eyes first using turn based mode, then the guards standing outside her interrogation room. I just found out that you can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. Like it could be something similar to shadow heart and laezel arguing and talking through things, minus the whole trying the kill each other in the middle After that I just beat everyone up, and I rescued Halsin, but I told him to stay in the prison. dunr xmhiw udxue pthv xsd beasjj qivps doai pklic rxxn